At the Creative Arts Emmy Awards show in September 2019, Rachel revealed she and husband Dan are expecting their first child, a baby girl. "I'm pregnant!" the actress told reporters backstage. She made the official announcement shortly after accepting her first-ever Emmy for outstanding original music and lyrics on the CW's Crazy Ex-Girlfriend. "I get to tell my child that she was with me when this happened, which is really f*cking cool," she added.