The duo first met while filming their 2014 dramedy "Vampire Academy," but it wasn't until a year later that they seemingly confirmed their romance when they were spotted kissing outside of the Warwick in Los Angeles in February 2015 and again at a basketball game later that March, per People. That same month, Entertainment Tonight reported that they got matching arrow tattoos.
"Sarah makes me want to be a better version of myself," Sherwood told ET in 2016. "That's what I love most about her. She inspires me to be the best version of me." After two years of dating, Sherwood and Hyland went their separate ways in 2017. "They aren't dating anymore but they both have mutual respect for one another and remain friends," a source told People about their breakup at the time.