Jonathan Bennett made audiences swoon when he played Lindsay Lohan's love interest in Mean Girls, but we haven't seen much of the hottie since his iconic 2004 role. Though he has landed some small roles since then, Bennett now serves as the host of Food Network's Halloween Wars, and he previously hosted Cake Wars as well. In 2018, he even released a pop culture cookbook called The Burn Cookbook with celebrity chef Nikki Martin, and he has no regrets about perpetually being known as Aaron Samuels. "It's the weirdest thing to be Aaron Samuels, because not a day goes by that someone doesn't come up to you and say something," he explained to Teen Vogue in 2017. "It's just part of my life, and I'm honoured to be part of people's lives."