Cruel Summer: Who Is Annabelle? Theories
Who the Eff Is Annabelle? 7 Theories About Cruel Summer's Latest Mystery
3
We know from Jeanette's sneaking around in Martin's house that before landing in Skylin, he was at the Widow Falls. The circumstances under which he left there are still unclear. But if the showrunners bothered to drop this little nugget in there, it must be the crumb leading somewhere, right? What if the reason for his transference was that he attempted to strike an inappropriate relationship with another student, named Annabelle who rejected his advances? For all we know, Kate wasn't his first victim, and that all that time, Annabelle was the one keeping Kate company.
In episode five, we see a '93 Martin harshly berating Jeanette for bailing on her date. Could that be coming from a personal place? @camA5802 on Twitter seems to think so. Intrigued!