The worlds of Cinderella and The Bachelor in Julie Murphy's modern day body-positive fairytale If the Shoe Fits. When Cindy moves back in with her stepmother Erica, the executive producer of the hit dating show Before Midnight, the last thing she expects to do is fill in for a contestant who dropped out of the program. Now Cindy and her homemade designer shoes are in the national spotlight. And while she initially saw the show as a way to give her fledgling career a boost, she soon finds she's falling for the show's prince charming for real.