Wayfair Sleep 11" Plush Pillow Top Innerspring Mattress plush The Mattress: Wayfair Sleep Plush Pillow Top Innerspring Mattress ($400, originally $443) Comfort Level: Plush The Thickness: 11 inches Why People Love It: If you're looking for a soft, plush, and cloud-like feel, this is a great choice for you. Customers who were looking for that, said they got the best night's sleep in years. Image Source: wayfair.com Wayfair Sleep Plush Pillow Top Innerspring Mattress $400 from wayfair.com Buy Now