This Strategy For Getting My Toddler to Listen Has Helped Me Parent Without Yelling

Photographer: Levi MandelRestrictions: Editorial and internal use only. No advertising or print allowed.
POPSUGAR Photography | Levi Mandel
POPSUGAR Photography | Levi Mandel
While each product featured is independently selected by our editors, we may include paid promotion. If you buy something through our links, we may earn commission. Read more about our Product Review Guidelines here.

My son turned three when I became pregnant with our second child, and toddlerhood suddenly threw a curve ball I had no idea how to catch. It seemed like the farther along I got in my pregnancy, the harder it was to get him to cooperate. The mornings and evenings when my husband was working and I was parenting solo were especially brutal. I'd run the gamut of parenting offence: pleading, bribing, threatening — and on my worse days — yelling.

In my desperation, I ordered How to Talk So Little Kids Will Listen by Joanna Faber and Julie King ($8) and it suggested a tool I had never thought to use: play. You might be thinking... how exactly do you play your way out of a tooth brushing stand off? And what if you're not in a playful mood? Isn't that a lot of exhausting creative work? And shouldn't my child learn how to do things because I ask him to? I had all of these thoughts, but let me explain what happened when I tried it.

It was indeed a tooth brush stand off that started the experiment. My toddler refused to open his mouth after I slathered his toothbrush with strawberry toothpaste and enthusiastically offered him a taste. "No! I don't want to brush my teeth." He said, folding his arms. My mind flashed to the shark documentary we had watched bits and pieces of over the weekend. "Hey!" I said, looking at his mouth and pointing curiously. "It looks like you're growing a shark tooth in there. Let me see!"

This piqued his interest. His eyes immediately lit up as he opened his mouth for me to take a peek. "Yes, you are! It's in the back. Let me touch it with the toothbrush to see if it's sharp," I said. He began to giggle a little with his mouth open. I began working the toothbrush around his molars, making my way through the rest of his mouth as I rattled off random shark stats and continued to comment on the tooth. It worked!

In fact, it worked so well that I continued to use the tactic throughout our getting-out-of-the-house routine. That morning, I was the voice for his empty shoes who were hungry for feet, I was a fellow Pterodactyl flying to the car with him to escape the fate of Sharp Tooth, the T-Rex. On the way to daycare, we hopped out of the car and held hands as we escaped lava. And as I kissed him goodbye, I realised how good I felt. Sure, getting out the door a little early felt great, but more than that, I was enjoying the silliness and fun. It added so much joy to what previously felt like one giant checklist, and we were connecting.

Do I used this tool to get my toddler to listen all the time? Honestly, no. There are days when I don't feel creative or particularly "sunny", as the authors put it. On those days, I reach back into my tool box and choose another approach. Being playful is a part-time tool that is a fantastic first resort. If you can muster it, you'll be shocked by how effective it is. Other tools, like offering kids a choice and giving them information instead of an order are also helpful, but there's something about play that can change the parent-toddler dynamic in an instant.