Best NYX Products on Amazon
See Why Reviewers Are Loving These 7 Bestselling NYX Products
7
The product: NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil Shadow Liner ($9)
The rating: 4.4 stars
Why customers like it: This pencil has over 1,200 positive reviews, and one customer loved its long-lasting shine. "This pencil hits all the marks! Creamy, dark, and lasts long. I only applied once and it stayed on fresh the whole day. Application is super smooth and nice."