Best Mascaras According to Editors
The Must-Have Mascaras Our Editors Keep Buying Over and Over
18
"I was convinced that drugstore mascaras were second tier, until I tried Covergirl's The SuperSizer. I like my lashes to have both length and volume; this mascara makes them stand out without feeling clumpy or like I need falsies. Also, it doesn't leave the dreaded under-eye runoff. I'm officially a drugstore convert, but only for this teal tube." — India Yaffe, editorial assistant, shop