Popsugar Celebrity Twitter Reactions Charlie Plummer and Chad Michael Murray Comparison Photos Looking For Alaska Fans Are Comparing Charlie Plummer to Chad Michael Murray, and We See It 22 October 2019 by Erin Cullum Image Source: Hulu Some Hulu viewers who've already watched Looking For Alaska, which premiered on Oct. 18, can't help but compare actor Charlie Plummer to another onscreen heartthrob: Chad Michael Murray. Charlie plays Miles "Pudge" Halter in the eight-episode series, which is based on John Green's bestselling YA novel, and between his blonde hair, brooding smile, and blue eyes, he does, in fact, bear a resemblance to the former One Tree Hill actor. It all started with a tweet by journalist Tara Watson, who shared a side-by-side comparison and said, "This actor has no business looking so much like Chad Michael Murray." People chimed in with their agreements that Charlie reminds them of Chad and his beloved character, Lucas Scott. Yes, Charlie's hair is much longer, and the 20-year-old is not exactly a dead ringer for 38-year-old Chad, but it's hard to ignore the similarities between him and a young Chad from the late 2000s during his OTH days. See side-by-side comparisons of the two actors ahead to decide for yourself. The Tweet Comparing Charlie Plummer to Chad Michael Murray This actor has no business looking so much like Chad Michael Murray. #LookingForAlaska pic.twitter.com/Hv7lWSsPzq— Tara Watson (@tara_watson_) October 19, 2019 1 / 17 People on Twitter Agreed Miles Halter is Lucas Scott reincarnated (with long hair). Even their voices and mannerisms are identical.— Amanda Lynn (@alswartfager) October 20, 2019 2 / 17 I had to do a search to see if they are related. Looks AND sounds just like him.— Breanna Rodenschmit (@brodenschmit) October 21, 2019 3 / 17 See More Comparisons For Yourself Ahead I genuinely thought it was CMM for a few seconds— Sarah Maunder (@s_maunder) October 19, 2019 4 / 17 Charlie Plummer in Looking For Alaska Image Source: Hulu 5 / 17 Charlie Plummer in Looking For Alaska Image Source: Hulu 6 / 17 Charlie Plummer in Looking For Alaska Image Source: Hulu 7 / 17 Charlie Plummer in Looking For Alaska Image Source: Hulu 8 / 17 Charlie Plummer in Looking For Alaska Image Source: Hulu 9 / 17 Chad Michael Murray in One Tree Hill Image Source: Everett Collection 10 / 17 Chad Michael Murray in One Tree Hill Image Source: Everett Collection 11 / 17 Chad Michael Murray in One Tree Hill Image Source: Everett Collection 12 / 17 Chad Michael Murray in One Tree Hill Image Source: Everett Collection 13 / 17 Chad Michael Murray in One Tree Hill Image Source: Everett Collection 14 / 17 Charlie Plummer and Chad Michael Murray Side-by-Side Image Sources: Getty / Jim Spellman and Getty / Jason LaVeris 15 / 17 Charlie Plummer and Chad Michael Murray Side-by-Side Image Sources: Getty / Rodin Eckenroth and Getty / Jamie McCarthy 16 / 17 Charlie Plummer and Chad Michael Murray Side-by-Side Image Sources: Getty / Presley Ann and Getty / Steve Granitz 17 / 17 Twitter ReactionsLooking For AlaskaChad Michael MurrayTVOne Tree Hill