Though the two never officially dated, Nick did have a pretty big crush on the singer in 2013 — so big that he actually ended up writing a song about her. The Jonas Brothers's track "What Do I Mean to You?" calls out Rita by name. Rita later clarified the whole ordeal during an appearance on Watch What Happens Live!, adding that whilst they were close, "it never went to that level." She eventually confronted Nick about the song and he confessed his true feelings. "It was one of those situations," she added. "He never really told me that I think, but regardless, we're still friends and I still have a lot of respect for him."