If you love high school rom-coms with secrets to be overcome, then this millennial icon is for you! Unpopular teenage waitress Sam has a secret life online, where she messages with "PrincetonGuy," her soulful, anonymous penpal. Little does she know that her online confidant is actually Austin, the most popular guy at her school, who is struggling with decisions about his future, too.
Pro tip: A Cinderella Story is scheduled to return to Netflix on Sept. 1, so mark your calendars!
Watch A Cinderella Story on HBO Max.