Beanie's older brother is none other than Academy Award-nominated actor Jonah Hill. When speaking with W, Beanie referred to Jonah, who is nine years her senior, as her best friend. "I just think he is the best and has the best taste," said the Lady Bird actress. " . . . We think the world of each other." To celebrate Beanie's Broadway debut in Hello, Dolly!, Jonah got the message "Hello, Beanie!" tattooed on his forearm. If that's not sibling love, we don't know what is!
Beanie and Jonah's other brother, Jordan, passed away suddenly after suffering from a pulmonary embolism in 2017. Jordan, who was only 40 at the time of his death, founded Career Artist Management (CAM) and was the longtime talent manager for Maroon 5.