Otis goes through some major ups and downs throughout season two, starting with him rejecting Maeve after she confesses her feeling for him. He dates Ola — who makes him cut Maeve off — but regrets his choice, especially after Ola breaks up with him. After getting drunk at a party and admitting he always liked Maeve and never really was into Ola, Otis eventually wakes up hungover, and realises he lost his virginity to Ruby. His mother discovers his clandestine "therapy clinic" for fellow students, even though he lies to her about it. At the end of the season, Otis leaves Maeve a voicemail to apologise and tell her he loves her, but Isaac listens to the message and deletes it before Maeve ever knows about it.